27 12
发新话题
打印

如何护卫真理?

如何护卫真理?

在辩论中,我们往往认为我们是在护卫真理,有时候倾向于使用极端性排斥性的结论。对于如何护卫真理,佛陀说道:
[佛陀:]"有五件做法,实时即地会产生两种果报。哪五件?信念、好感、不破坏传统、模拟推理、藉思考达成同感。正是这五件做法,实时即地会产生两种果报。不过有些事虽然人们坚信,却是空洞、空虚、虚假的。有些事虽然人们并不坚信,却是真实、事实、无误的。有些事虽然人们极有好感……有些事确非破坏传统……有些事人们虽多方推理……有些事人们虽多方思索,却是空洞、空虚、虚假的。有些事人们并不反复思索,却是真实、事实、无误的。一位护卫真理的有识之士,不适于得出这样绝对的结论: '只有这是真的,其它毫无价值。'"
[伽巴提迦-跋罗陀瓦伽:]"但是,乔达摩大师,到什么地步,一个人才能护卫真理?我们请教乔达摩大师关于真理的护卫。"
[佛陀:]"如果一个人有信念,他说'这是我的信念'这话就护卫了真理。但是他不至于得出 '只有这是真的,其它毫无价值' 这样的绝对结论。跋罗陀瓦伽,到了这个地步,就是对真理的护卫。到了这个地步,他就护卫了真理。我把它称为对真理的护卫。但这还不是对真理的觉醒。"--MN95(中部,坦尼沙罗尊者英译)
我们爱智慧微博:http://weibo.com/upekkha

TOP

来个故事吧:
我落水了,别人将我救上来。
我说:“谢谢!”
他回答:“不用谢,我们教儒家的老师经常这样教我。”
我说:“你们是外道。我不谢谢你们了。”
我们爱智慧微博:http://weibo.com/upekkha

TOP

回复 2# chzhuang 的帖子

不是所有的人都是您讲的这么傻B
被救人道谢属于个人修养道德,和宗教信仰以及文化差异,怎么可以混为举例,真是滑稽

[ 本帖最后由 傲笑 于 2011-5-26 11:58 编辑 ]

TOP

引用:
原帖由 傲笑 于 2011-5-26 11:56 发表
不是所有的人都是您讲的这么傻B
被救人道谢属于个人修养道德,和宗教信仰以及文化差异,怎么可以混为举例,真是滑稽
个体修养与宗教信仰可以分裂吗?
所以要随喜他人的好的行为。儒家教他救人,这也是应该随喜。
一切功德皆随喜!
我们爱智慧微博:http://weibo.com/upekkha

TOP

回复 4# chzhuang 的帖子

希特勒不是个人和他的宗教信仰分裂了吗?要是都绑定,那么基督教成什么了。这个问题太简单了!

TOP

引用:
原帖由 傲笑 于 2011-5-26 12:55 发表
希特勒不是个人和他的宗教信仰分裂了吗?要是都绑定,那么基督教成什么了。这个问题太简单了!
据我所知,希特勒信仰的是尼采的强力意志。
另外,即使如你所说,有些人虽然接受某些信仰,但是却没有真正去做。那也并不能否定:还是有些人按照信仰,真正地去做。
有些人可能接受儒家信仰,但是他不救人。但是这并不能否定:有些人接受了儒家信仰,然后去救人了。

以儒家为例,应该承认大部分中国人的正面的善的个人修养,或多或少地,与儒家的教导有关联。这点师兄可以承认吗?

为什么佛教可以在中华扎根?师兄考虑过吗?
我们爱智慧微博:http://weibo.com/upekkha

TOP

回复 6# chzhuang 的帖子

我是说你举例有问题,你举例儒家弟子救人,被救的人因为对方是儒家而不道谢,本来这个例子就很狗血。
其他的离题太远,扯下来就没完没了了,你叫我承认的我从来没反对,不至于还要宣誓才能证明吧。
希特勒是信仰基督教,这点没什么疑问的。

TOP

Hitler's religiou? beliefs and fanatici?m

(Selected quotes from Mein Kampf)

compiled by Jim Walker

Originated: 28 Nov. 1996
Addition? made: 07 July 2001
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

People often make the claim that Adolph Hitler adhered to Athei?m, Humani?m or some ancient Nordic pagan mythology. None of these fanciful and wrong ideas hold. Although one of Hitler's henchmen, Alfred Rosenberg, did undertake a campaign of Nordic mythological propaganda, Hitler and most of his henchmen did not believe in it .

Many American books, television documentaries, and Sunday sermons that preach of Hitler's "evil" have eliminated Hitler's god for their Christian audience?, but one only has to read from his own writings to appreciate that Hitler's God equals the same God of the Christian Bible. Hitler held many hysterical beliefs which not only include, God and Providence but also Fate, Social Darwini?m, and ideological politics. He spoke, unashamedly, about God, fanatici?m, ideali?m, dogma, and the power of propaganda. Hitler held strong faith in all his convictions. He justified his fight for the German people and against Jew? by using Godly and Biblical reasoning. Indeed, one of hi? most revealing statement? makes this quite clear:

"Hence today I believe that I am acting in accordance with the will of the Almighty Creator: by defending myself against the Jew, I am fighting for the work of the Lord."

Although Hitler did not practice religion in a churchly sense, he certainly believed in the Bible's God. Raised as Catholic he went to a monastery school and, interestingly, walked everyday past a stone arch which was carved the monastery's coat of arms which included a swastika. As a young boy, Hitler's most ardent goal was to become a priest. Much of his philosophy came from the Bible, and more influentially, from the Christian Social movement. (The German Christian Social movement, remarkably, resembles the Christian Right movement in America today.) Many have questioned Hitler's stand on Christianity. Although he fought against certain Catholic priests who opposed him for political reasons, hi? belief in God and country never left him. Many Christians throughout history have opposed Christian priests for various reasons; this does not necessarily make one against one's own Christian beliefs. Nor did the Vatican's Pope & bishops ever disown him; in fact they blessed him! As evidence to his claimed Christianity, he said:

"My feelings as a Christian points me to my Lord and Savior as a fighter. It points me to the man who once in loneliness, surrounded by a few followers, recognized these Jews for what they were and summoned men to fight against them and who, God's truth! was greatest not as a sufferer but as a fighter. In boundless love as a Christian and as a man I read through the passage which tells us how the Lord at last rose in His might and seized the scourge to drive out of the Temple the brood of vipers and adders. How terrific was His fight for the world against the Jewish poison. To-day, after two thousand years, with deepest emotion I recognize more profoundly than ever before the fact that it was for this that He had to shed Hi? blood upon the Cross. As a Christian I have no duty to allow myself to be cheated, but I have the duty to be a fighter for truth and justice... And if there is anything which could demonstrate that we are acting rightly it is the distress that daily grows. For as a Christian I have also a duty to my own people.
-Adolf Hitler, in a speech on 12 April 1922 (Norman H. Baynes, ed. The Speeches of Adolf Hitler, April 1922-August 1939, Vol. 1 of 2, pp. 19-20, Oxford University Press, 1942)

Hitler's anti-Semitism grew out of his Christian education. Christian Austria and Germany in his time took for granted the belief that Jews held an inferior status to Aryan Christians. Jewish hatred did not spring from Hitler, it came from the preaching of Catholic priests and Protestant ministers throughout Germany for hundreds of years. The Protestant leader, Martin Luther, himself, held a livid hatred for Jews and their Jewish religion. In hi? book, "On the Jews and their Lies," Luther set the standard for Jewish hatred in Protestant Germany up until World War II. Hitler expressed a great admiration for Martin Luther.

Hitler did not have to parade hi? belief in God, as so many American Christians do now. Nor did he have to justify his Godly belief against an Atheist movement. He took hi? beliefs for granted just as most Germans did at that time. His thrust aimed at politics, not religion. But through his political and religious reasoning he established in 1933, a German Reich Christian Church, uniting the Protestant churches to instill faith in a national German Christianity.

Future generations should remember that Adolph Hitler could not have come into power without the support of the Protestant and Catholic churches and the German Christian populace.

The following quotes provides some of Hitler's expressions of hi? belief in religion, faith, fanaticism, Providence, and even a few of his paraphrasing of the Bible. It by no means represents the totality of Hitler's concerns. To realize the full context of these quotes, I implore the reader to study Mein Kampf.

The purpose of this text intends to dispute the claims made by Christians that Hitler "was an atheist," or "anti-religious," and to reveal the dangers of belief-systems. This text in no way attempts to give endorsement to anti-Semitism.

TOP

引用:
原帖由 傲笑 于 2011-5-26 13:18 发表
我是说你举例有问题,你举例儒家弟子救人,被救的人因为对方是儒家而不道谢,本来这个例子就很狗血。
其他的离题太远,扯下来就没完没了了,你叫我承认的我从来没反对,不至于还要宣誓才能证明吧。
希特勒是信仰基 ...
我举的例子是说明一些极端的情况:排斥儒家的善行。
那我们就观点相同了。
我们爱智慧微博:http://weibo.com/upekkha

TOP

引用:
原帖由 傲笑 于 2011-5-26 11:56 发表
不是所有的人都是您讲的这么傻B
被救人道谢属于个人修养道德,和宗教信仰以及文化差异,怎么可以混为举例,真是滑稽
请注意文明用语!你这人也真是的!

chzhuang讲的这个故事,只是假设,不是真事儿,故事情节上也不够彻底,的确不怎么能够说明问题。听说对方是“外道”,不是“谢”与“不谢”的问题,而是,是否接受援救的问题,如果一旦听说对方是“外道”,是不是要转身跳回水里,以示清白、彻底与“外道”决裂?

我来讲一个真人真事儿吧,情节完全属实,绝无半点虚构:

2008年中秋节,突然接到北京舅妈打来的电话,说舅舅突感呼吸困难,经医院检查为癌症晚期,心肺、胸腔大量积液,恐不久人世。

我闻讯急忙赶赴北京,到医院去看望舅舅。见舅舅呼吸困难、痛苦万状,于是,便试探着问舅舅和舅妈,是否愿意接受佛教的一些方法协助治疗?遭到了舅舅和舅妈异口同声的断然拒绝。舅舅和舅妈都是基督教徒,因此拒绝佛教,也本是在情理之中。

但是,因为舅舅的心肺、胸腔积液很是严重,造成了呼吸极度困难,医生一再让他尽量多做深呼吸练习,可是舅舅病情已重,无法完成。万般无奈之下,我只好经向恩师请示之后,教给了舅舅一个练习呼吸的方法,但是没有告诉舅舅实情,只对舅舅说,那是一种“气功”的方法,舅舅信以为真,便接受了,并且经过练习,也确实感觉呼吸比先改善了很多。。。

宗教本身,应该是引导人们寻求真理、发现真理,不应是鼓动人们狂热于宗教的形态而排斥异己。舅舅的例子,就很悲剧,即如那个故事里的落水人,不仅不会说一个“谢”字,而且干脆跳回水里,坚决的予以拒绝。。。

TOP

我们讨论的道教,与老子无关。
我们讨论的儒教,与孔子无关。


[ 本帖最后由 chzhuang 于 2011-5-26 13:36 编辑 ]
我们爱智慧微博:http://weibo.com/upekkha

TOP

尘露师兄的例子挺说明问题。

为什么会有宗教?
老子没有创立道教,耶稣没有创立基督教,孔子更是与宗教不沾边。
他们只是教导他们的智慧,传播他们的光明与慈爱。
我们爱智慧微博:http://weibo.com/upekkha

TOP

从百法明门论来看,宗教是属于什么法?
我们爱智慧微博:http://weibo.com/upekkha

TOP

再从唯识来看,宗教属于什么法?
遍计所执?依他起?
我们爱智慧微博:http://weibo.com/upekkha

TOP

回复 10# 尘露 的帖子

按照基督教的教义,信仰别的宗教是要下地狱的,你让您的舅舅临终做些佛教的事儿,那不是很让人无法接受吗?如果一个念佛去净土的佛教徒,临终时来个基督徒说,读读圣经吧,你会通体舒坦,那不是很招人厌。

TOP

 27 12
发新话题
最近访问的版块